|

By Steve Lee, APR
Just a year ago, the media was sounding alarms for the future
of U.S. "bricks and mortar" retailers. Internet-only
("pure-play") companies were stealing their customers
and their sales at a rapid rate. The times were clearly changing
and the retail landscape looked to be the proving ground for a
new digital age. Then something amazing happened -- reality struck.
Simultaneously, two important things happened. First, major brands
like the Gap, Toys "R" Us, Staples, Home Depot, and Merrill
Lynch repositioned themselves into "clicks and mortar" organizations
-- offering both the traditional business services as well as Internet-based
services. And secondly, the money ran out. Or, more pointedly,
investor's patience with waiting for the return-on-investment ran
out.
You see, what the dot-com-onlys have is great Internet presence,
but limited business understanding. They have no history of serving
and satisfying customer needs and seemingly little knowledge of
who the customer is and what they want. In their rush to the market
they assumed that the world had changed, that the Internet had
ushered in a brave new world of commerce where the rules were different.
What they misunderstood is that people are still people and business
is still business. Consumer expectations haven't changed -- just
our shopping patterns.
This turn of fortunes has left many Internet-only companies scrambling
to find their place. In a special e-commerce report in The Wall
Street Journal Interactive Edition, Ted Dintersmith, a partner
with the venture-capital firm Charles River Ventures, is quoted
as saying, "These [Internet only] companies are like pilots
flying into a canyon and suddenly finding they can't climb fast
enough to get out and there's no reverse."
The record shows that "click and mortar" companies are
making more sales on the Web than their Internet-only competition:
"Click
and mortar" companies lead in most sales categories
Sources: Shop.org, Boston Consulting
Group |
| Sales
of: |
"Click
and Mortar" companies |
Internet-only
companies |
| Event
Tickets |
97% |
3% |
| Computer
hardware/software |
82% |
18% |
| Apparel/sporting |
81% |
19% |
| Flowers/cards/gifts |
80% |
20% |
| Home/garden |
76% |
24% |
| Financial
brokerage |
73% |
27% |
| Automotive |
63% |
37% |
| Travel |
58% |
42% |
| Consumer
electronics |
57% |
43% |
| Health/beauty |
55% |
45% |
| Toys |
29% |
71% |
| Books |
26% |
74% |
| Music/video |
15% |
85% |
| Averages |
61% |
39% |
But why has it taken traditional American businesses so long to
embrace the Internet? In a Forbes article entitled "The E
Gang," Jack Welch explained his Internet reluctance saying "I
was afraid of it, because I couldn't type." Then he spent
a weekend at the keyboard, and General Electric has never been
the same. The big old guys are going to beat the daylights out
of the pure-play dot-commers, says Welch. "Old companies thought
this was Nobel Prize-type work. This is not rocket science. It's
just like breathing." Carly Fiorina, CEO of Hewlett-Packard
says, "People who concluded in the first couple of years of
the Internet boom that the large companies would fail and only
the new ones would succeed fundamentally misunderstood the true
transformational power of the Internet."
Obviously, the Internet has changed the dynamics of how we shop.
Information is much more freely available and dependence on retail
experts (salespeople) has all but vanished. But no matter how much
information we now have, shoppers' expectations haven't changed.
Value and service are still in high demand and the retailer who
delivers these will ultimately win.
Companies' senior managements glibly talk of "exceeding expectations," but
customers are delighted when their expectations are just met. Forget
exceeded!
In dealing with "bricks and mortar" companies, customers
know what to expect and there is comfort and trust in this familiarity.
Let's face it, consumers want their expectations to be met, but
they don't like to be surprised. At one time, Holiday Inn used
the advertising slogan, "The best surprise is no surprise." The "line" may
have disappeared, but travelers still know what to expect when
they drive into a Holiday Inn.
The equity that has been built in major brands communicates much
more than just a name; it tells consumers what level of quality,
service and value they will get when they shop, either online or
in a "real" store at Blockbuster, RadioShack, Toys "R" Us
or other major retailers. Having an established relationship with
customers in the physical world makes it much cheaper to relate
to them online. Boston Consulting Group says it costs Internet-only
retailers $82 to acquire a new customer, compared with $31 for
store-based retailers to get an online customer and just $11 for
catalog-based retailers. There is a natural synergy between retail
stores and web sites, if the company only knows how to leverage
the two to work together.
Consumers with incomes high enough to excite retailers usually
like to buy recognized brands. They like bargains, but they don't
want to spend the time necessary to "shop around." Established "click
and mortar" companies understand this and use their brand
names to attract well-heeled prospects. They are experienced enough
to know that their stores and their brands are their greatest assets.
They use their Internet sites to fend off the competition, using
the philosophy that "If somebody's going to sell on the Internet,
it may as well be us."
The managements of the "pure-play" companies often
are young and inexperienced. Their enchantment with technology
overshadows their belief that the customers' needs will be met
or the customer will go somewhere else. Even though surveys constantly
point to customers' demand for complete information, clear graphics,
on-time delivery and personalized (human-based) customer service,
the lack of customer understanding, coupled with a complete lack
of physical presence (stores) often makes dealing with an Internet-only
company frustrating. If it sounds like the pendulum has swung and
now the dot.coms are out of hope, don't believe it. Who would have
foreseen the changes we've watched cross the business landscape
in just the past few years? The full impact the Internet will have
on our daily lives remains to be seen. We've only experienced a
small part of what is to come.
For businesses, the Internet is both curse and blessing. On one
hand it speeds time-to-market tremendously and allows you to have
a direct dialogue with the customer -- while on the other hand
it exposes your flaws and gives the consumer a very loud voice
when aroused. In the end, the basic tenants of business don't change.
Deliver a quality product in a timely and convenient manner, price
it competitively and back it with good customer service. Those
are the attributes that Stanley Marcus used to build Neiman-Marcus,
and they're the attributes that make companies successful today,
on and off the Internet.
|